Ashiqui 2 is an Indian romantic film directed by Mohit Suri and acted by Aditya Roy Kapoor and shraddha Kapoor in the lead roles.And The Artist is French romantic comedy drama written and directed by Michel Hazaravicins and acted by Jean Dujardin and Berenie. Both of them have the same plot dealing with the predicament of the artist and romantic love affair and its effect on their personal lives. Here, I am trying to make a comparative study.
In 1927, silent film star George Valentin is posing for pictures
outside the premiere of his latest hit film when a young woman, Peppy
Miller, accidentally bumps into him. Valentin reacts with humor to the
accident and shows off with Peppy for the cameras. The next day, Peppy
finds herself on the front page of
with the headline "Who's That Girl?" Later, Peppy auditions as a dancer
and is spotted by Valentin, who insists that she have a part in
Kinograph Studios' next production, despite objections from the studio
boss, Al Zimmer. While performing a scene together, Valentin and Peppy
show great chemistry, despite her being merely an extra. With a little
guidance from Valentin (he draws a on her, which will eventually be her trademark, after finding her in
his dressing room), Peppy slowly rises through the industry, earning
more prominent starring roles.
Two years later, Zimmer announces the end of production of silent
films at Kinograph Studios, but Valentin is dismissive, insisting that
sound is just a fad. In a dream, Valentin begins hearing sounds from his
environment (as does the audience), but cannot speak himself, then
wakes up in a sweat. He decides to produce and direct his own silent
film, financing it himself. The film opens within a few days of Peppy's
new sound film as well as the.
Now Valentin's only chance of avoiding bankruptcy is for his film to be
a hit. Unfortunately audiences flock to Peppy's film instead and
Valentin is ruined. His wife, Doris, kicks him out, and he moves into an
apartment with his valet/chauffeur, Clifton, and his dog. Peppy goes on
to become a major Hollywood star.
Later, the bankrupt Valentin is forced to auction off all of his
personal effects, and fires Clifton, telling him to get another job.
Depressed and drunk, Valentin angrily sets a match to his private
collection of his earlier films. As the
quickly blazes out of control he is overwhelmed by the smoke and passes
out inside the burning house, still clutching a single film canister.
However, Valentin's dog attracts the help of a nearby policeman, and
after being rescued Valentin is hospitalized for injuries suffered in
the fire. Peppy visits the hospital and discovers that the film he
rescued is the one she was first in. She asks for him to be moved to her
house to recuperate. Valentin awakens in a bed at her house, to find
that Clifton is now working for Peppy. Valentin seems to remain
dismissive of Peppy having taken him in, prompting Clifton to sternly
remind Valentin of his changing luck.
Peppy insists to Zimmer that Valentin co-star in her next film,
threatening to quit Kinograph if Zimmer does not agree to her terms.
After Valentin learns to his dismay that it had been Peppy who had
purchased all his auctioned effects, he returns in despair to his
burnt-out apartment. Peppy arrives, panicked, and finds that Valentin is
about to attempt suicide. The two reconcile, and remembering Valentin's
superb dancing ability, Peppy persuades Zimmer to let them make a together.
Now the audience hears sound for the second time, as the film starts
rolling for a dance scene with Peppy and Valentin and their tap-dancing
can be heard. Once the choreography is complete, the two dancers are
heard panting. The director of the musical calls out audibly, "Cut!" to
which Zimmer adds: "Perfect. Beautiful. Could you give me one more?"
Valentin, in his only audible line, replies "With pleasure!" revealing
his
. The camera then pulls back to the sounds of the film crew as they prepare to shoot another take.
Recently released Bollywood movie Ashiqui share more or less same plot with Indian romantic love flavor. Rahul Jaykar is an successful but lonely musician whose career has
started to wane due to his alchohol addiction ,which subsequently affect
his voice . His friend Vivek & boss (Played by mahesh thakur) urges
him to leave the habit & focus on his career but he is not able to
do so. During a concert he comes in contact with Arohi ,who idolize him
,while he is smitten by her simplicity & voice .He promises her to
mentor her career but is unable to do so due to a medical emergency.
When Rahul recupartes he finds arohi again & apologise & began
to train her,despite vivek reservation .He also approaches different
music firms to give her chance & at last his old boss agrees for it.
Arohi is an instant hit & people began to compare Rahul & Arohi
which angers him & he again go into alcohol spree . However Arohi
,who love's Rahul more than her career soothes him & they spend the
night together .Despite Arohi's mother reservations ,Arohi moves in with
Rahul .Things go smoothly but Rahul addiction increases with his career
downfall so much that he began to have violent episodes with fellow
workers . Some of this also embaress Arohi ,but still her love makes her
try to reform Rahul again . It would seem that Rahul has finally return
to right track but during an award ceremony ,due to some reporter
instigation ,he again has a violent alteracation & is put in lockup
,after slapping Arohi. Arohi ,despite his boss advice that Rahul cannot
be brought back ,pleads with the police officer to leave him & the
officer relent .During that night ,Arohi says to his boss that if
required she will also absorb Rahul's habit so that he find solace with
her . This finally make Rahul understand that he has become the only
center of Arohi life & his love & presence will not allow her to
move on unless he goes away . The next day he makes some excuse to
arohi,bid her farewell & jumps from a bridge. Arohi is distraught by
this & decides to move away somewhere else but vivek encourages her
to not waste Rahul Sacrifice by burning her career & going the same
route that Rahul took.The end segment shows Arohi to be a succesful
singer & she sees Rahul in the audience whenever she performs .The
film end with Arohi signing her name as Arohi Rahul Jayekar in a fan's
hand as a tribute to Rahul as well as her unfinished desire to become
Rahul's wife.
Both of these movies show how artists fade away in course of time if they cant catch the current of new trends. Both of the artists are drunk and a big snob which becomes the cause of their downfall. But the heroines, in the both plays are picked up by the artist and made them star. Finally, they become the super star. The Artist has a happy ending ; whereas Ishaqui 2 has a tragic end.